The on-going row about antisemitism within the Labour party generates strong emotions across the community.

Some argue that Jews should have nothing to do with the party until it takes what they regard as serious action to tackle the issue.  This is an understandable response, which I had to weigh in the balance when York Labour’s Equalities Committee invited me to provide training on antsemitism to local party members.

Last Summer, York Central MP, Rachael Maskell – who is a regular at YLJC events and services – reached out to me to seek the community’s views on antisemitism within the party and to understand what she could to help.   Rachael was fully aware that I was an active member of the Liberal Democrats but was happy to seek advice whatever the source, which must be to her credit.

The issue of training, which was first mooted in November, took some time to come together.  I decided to partner with Mikki Vyse from the Jewish Leadership Council to provide professional input.

Eventually, it took place on Sunday 17thFebruary at the Tang Hall Community Centre.  Mikki and I were joined by Gabby Weiss, Emmett Stone and Sam Borin from the local Jewish community, who together provided a range of perspectives.  We were all pleasantly surprised to find over fifty Labour members prepared to give up their Sunday afternoon for the session, including the local party chair and a number of councillors and council candidates, as well of course as Rachael Maskell herself.

We agreed between us that content of the meeting should remain confidential, so I won’t comment on it here.  Nevertheless, personally, I was impressed by the constructive engagement of all those present.  I came away confident that, in the York Labour party at least, there is a real determination to get to grips with this issue.

Speaking after the event, Rachael Maskell said:  “ The antisemitism training provided by York’s Liberal Jewish Community was not only informative but also created a safe space for dialogue. I believe that through working together we have been able to build bridges, not barriers, and I thank everyone for their commitment in this.”

Jewish communal organisations continue understandably to pile pressure on the Labour leadership to deal more effectively with the hundreds of outstanding complaints about antisemitism, and some refuse to meet with them until they do. Despite this, I left in no doubt that a bottom-up approach, working proactively with the party’s grassroots, has the potential to complement a more hard line national approach.

The York Labour Party should be congratulated for their efforts.



Ben Rich



  1. This is very encouraging. I speak as someone who has encountered hostility in the workplace (in York Hospital that led to my departure), at both of York’s University’s (that led to my leaving training and study programmes) and in several social encounters, a hostility that seems to have got worse since the Millennium and most definitely since I became a member of Sinai Reform in 2009, despite my best efforts to hide my Jewish identity and engagement with Judaism. York is blessed with a very decent MP and there are many people in this city who are benign if not kindly and supportive of Jews and Jewish community here. Those who aren’t friendly, if not hostile, are in the minority. A far greater problem is the ignorance of many of York’s residents, that can lead to very insensitive and unpleasant comments to our Jewish ears. The only way to meet these problems of hostility and ignorance is through engagement, so this initiative is most welcome, so I applaud York Labour Party for inviting you and you for taking up their invitation. What I would suggest, however, is that the problems of hostility and ignorance are not peculiar or particular to members of the Labour Party, but spread right across the communities/population of York, nor confined to a particular class of people. My experience is that it is to be found among the better educated and wealthier inhabitants and others to be encountered in this lovely city. But as I say, I’m encouraged by this initiative.

    • How terrible to be so uncomfortable as to feel compelled to leave your workplace!! Antisemitism pure and simple comes from sheer ignorance of the noble ideals and principles of leading a Jewish life….. the answer MUST be to reach out, make friends and explain….. Gwen

  2. I’m sorry to hear about your experiences. However, you refer again to “hostility and ignorance” in York Labour Party. If you can substantiate this, then please make a formal complaint. However, I suspect it is untrue (or I have misunderstood you).

  3. Dear John (John Bibby),
    If you’re referring to my posting of March 2019, I make the point that ignorance and hostility towards Jews isn’t particular to the Labour Party or York Labour Party.
    I’ve experienced experienced verbal and physical threats to my person at York University, alas not taken seriously or competently by York University, which have been reported to North Yorkshire Police in July 2019. So clearly in that case of what the police have recorded as instances of hate crime, the problem is one that York University needed and still needs to address, which is why the matter is going to be referred to the Independent Adjudicator for UK universities in 2020. No connection with the Labour Party or York Labour Party has been alleged.
    My most recent experience of confrontational and hostile behaviour towards me in connection with my Jewish identity and Jewish Community assiciations occurred in two incidents in December 2019 at St Wilfrids Church now known as the York Oratory, so with no connection with the Labour Party or York Labour Party.
    As I’ve argued previously, antisemitism is not particular to supporters or members of a particular political party, nor are antisemites confined to people of disadvantaged backgrounds. The person confronting me over my ethnic and religious identity and observance and casting aspersions on my association with Jewish Community is educated to post-graduate level and is a qualified teacher working in secondary school (not in York or North Yorkshire, but, I believe, in Doncaster in South Yorkshire).

  4. Thanks Adrian, only just seen this.
    I’m relieved to see your comments incriminate the church and the university, not the Labour Party.

Leave a Reply